Penambahan Teknik Manual Therapy Pada Latihan Pendular Codman Lebih Meningkatkan Lingkup Gerak Sendi Pada Sendi Glenohumeral Penderita Frozen Shoulder

Salim JS

Abstract


Latar belakang:Keterbatasan gerakan ke segala  arah ciri khas dari penderita  frozen shoulder, dan banyak dijumpai di berbagai lahan praktek fisioterapi. Para fisioterapis sering tertantang karena terapi pada penderita frozen shoulder umumnya memerlukan waktu yang panjang untuk memperoleh aktivitas fungsional. Akhir-akhir ini Latihan Pendular Codman diragukan efektivitasnya untuk meningkatkan ROM sendi glenohumeral pada penderita frozen shoulder. Sebaliknya beberapa  penelitian dan studi kasus membuktikan teknik Manual Therapy efektif memperbaiki hipomobilitas pada penderita frozen shoulder. Tujuan:Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk membuktikan efektivitas penambahan teknik Manual Therapy pada Latihan Pendular Codman lebih meningkatkan Lingkup Gerak Sendi pada sendi glenohumeral daripada Latihan Pendular Codman pada  penderita frozen shoulder. Metode:Penelitian ini menggunakan metode eksperimental murni dengan pre-test dan post-test control group design. Eksperimen ini dilaksanakan di Praktek Fisioterapi, “Sriwijaya†Medan. Sampel penelitian berjumlah 16 orang yang dibagi ke dalam 2 kelompok sampel yaitu 8 orang pada kelompok kontrol dan 8 orang pada kelompok perlakuan. Kelompok kontrol yang diberikan intervensi Latihan  Pendular Codman dan kelompok perlakuan yang diberikan  teknik Manual Therapy dan Latihan Pendular Codman. Alat ukur yang digunakan untuk pengumpulan data adalah goniometer, dimana goniometer digunakan untuk mengukur lingkup gerak fleksi, ekstensi, abduksi, eksotorotasi dan endorotasi  baik sebelum intervensi maupun sesudah intervensi. Hasil:Hasil pengujian hipotesis dengan menggunakan uji t-test independent untuk fleksi, ekstensi, abduksi,  endorotasi dan uji Mann-Whitney Test untuk eksorotasi. Hasil pengujian hipotesis menunjukkan adanya perbedaan yang signifikan antara rerata sesudah intervensi ROM fleksi, ekstensi, abduksi, eksorotasi dan endorotasi pada sendi glenohumeral kelompok kontrol dan rerata sesudah intervensi ROM  kelompok perlakuan, dengan nilai p < 0,05. Kesimpulan: Penambahan teknik Manual Therapy pada Latihan Pendular Codman lebih efektif meningkatkan ROM sendi glenohumeral daripada  Latihan Pendular Codman pada penderita frozen shoulder. Peningkatan ROM sendi glenohumeral secara signifikan akan mengoptimalkan aktivitas fungsional sendi glenohumeral.

 Kata kunci :frozen shoulder,  teknik manual therapy, latihan pendular codman.

 

 Abstract

Background:Limitation of movement in all directions is the characteristic of patients with frozen shoulder, and often found in various fields of physiotherapy practice.The physiotherapist is often challenged therapy in patients with frozen shoulder; the patient usually requires a long time to find out the best functional activity. Lately, the  effectiveness of Codman’spendulum exercises was in doubt as a method to increase  the range of motion for frozen shoulder in glenohumeral joint patients. Instead, some research and case studies have proven manual therapy  techniques effectively repair hipomobility in patients with frozen shoulder.Objective:This study aims to prove the effectiveness of the addition of manual therapy techniques on  Codman’s pendulum exercises in inreasing the range of motion in patients with frozen shoulder in the glenohumeral joint.  Method:This study is true experimental research, the methods pre-test and post-test  control group design. The ekperiment was conducted in Physiotherapy Practice “ Sriwijaya†Medan. This study sample of 16 people were divided into 2 groups, 8 people in the control group and 8 people in the treatment group. A control group given  Codman’s pendulum exercises and a treatment group who was given the manual therapy techniques and  Codman’s pendulum exercises. The measuring instrument used for data collection was the goniometer.The goniometer was used to measure the range of motion of flexion, extension, abduction, exorotation, and endorotation of both pre-intervention and post-intervention. Results of the hypothesis were gathered by using the independent t-test for flexion, extension, abduction, endorotation,  and the Mann-Whitney test for exorotation. Result:Hypothesis testing results showed that significant difference in post-intervention mean of the control group and the mean of the treatment group for Range Of Motion (ROM) of the glenohumeral joint in flexion, extension, abduction, endorotation, exorotation, with a value of p < 0.05. Conclusion: The addition of manual therapy techniques on the Codman’s pendulum exercise is better than just Codman’s pendulum exercises in increasing ROM for frozen shoulder in glenohumeral joint patients. The increased ROM of the glenohumeral joints will significantly affect the activity of the glenohumeral joint and help it to function optimally.

 Keywords : frozen shoulder, manual therapy techniques, codman’s pendulum  exercise.


References


Andrews, J.R., Harrelson, G.L., Wilk, K.E. “Physical Rehabilitation of the Injured Athleteâ€, 4th edition, Mosby Elsevier,Philadelphia, 2012

Brotzman, S.B., Manske, R.C,“Clinical Orthopaedic Rehabilitation an Evidence-Based Approachâ€, third edition, Elsevier,Philadelphia, 2011

Cook, C.E, “Orthopedic Manual Therapy An Evidence-Based Approachâ€, first edition, Pearson Education LTD,Canada,2007

Diercks, R.L., Stevens, M,“Gentle thawing of the frozen shoulder : a prospective study of supervised neglect versus intensive physical therapy in seventy-seven patients with frozen shoulder syndrome followed up for two yearsâ€, TheJournal Shoulder Elbow surg, 13: 499-502,2004

Donatelli, R.A,“Physical Therapy of The Shoulderâ€, fourth edition, Churchill Livinston,Philadelphia, 2004

Durall, C,“Adhesiva Capsulitisâ€,second edition,In : Brotzman, S.B., Manske, R.C., editors,Clinical Orthopedic Rehabilitation :an evidence-based, Elsevier,Philadelphia, 2011

Edmond, S.L,“Joint mobilization/manipulation, extremity and spinal techniquesâ€,second edition, Mosby Elsevier,New Jersey, 2006

Egmond, D.L., Schuitemaker, R,“Extremiteiten manuele therapie in enge en ruime zin, 9dedrukâ€,Bohn Stafleu van Loghum,Houten,2006

Ellsworth, A.A., Mullaney, M., Tyler, T.F., McHugh, M., Nicholas, S.J, “Electromyography of selected shoulder musculature during un-weighted and weighted pendulum exercisesâ€, TheJournal Sports Phys Ther, 1(2) : 73-79,2006

Földi, M,“Foundation of Manual Lymph Drainageâ€, 3rd Edition, Elsevier,Missouri USA,2005

Griggs, S.M., Ahn, A., Green, A,“Idiopathic adhesive capsulitis, apospective functional outcome study of nonoperative treatmentâ€,The Journal Bone Joint Surg Am, 82: 1398-1407,2000

Hannafin, J.A., Chiaia, T.A,“Adhesive capsulitis: a treatment approachâ€,Clin Orthop Related Res, 372: 95-109, 2000

Holey, E., Cook, E,“Evidence-based Therapeutic Massageâ€, Second Edition, Churchill Livingstone,London, 2008

Hsu, J.E., Anakwenze, O.A., Warrander, W.J., Abboud, J.A,“Current review of adhesive capsulitisâ€.The Journal Shoulder Elbow Surg, 20: 502-514,2011

Johnson, A.J., Godges, J.J., Zimmerman, G.J,“The effect of anterior versus posterior glide joint mobilization on external rotation range of motion in patients with shoulder adhesive capsulitisâ€,The Journal Orthop Sports Phys Ther, 37(3): 88-99,2007

Jurgel, J., Rannama, L., Gapeyeva, H, “Shoulder function in patients with frozen shoulder before and after 4-week rehabilitationâ€,The Journal Medicina (Kaunas), 41: 30-38,2005

Kelley, M.J., Mcclure, P.W., Leggin, B.G,“Frozen shoulder : evidence and a proposed model guiding rehabilitationâ€,J Orthop Sports Phys Ther, 39(2): 135-148,2009

Lee, J.C., Sykes, C., Saifudin,“Adhesive capsulitis: sonographic changes in the rotator cuff interval with arthroscopic correlationâ€,Skeletal Radiol, 34: 361-368,2005

Magee, D.J,“Orthopedic Physical Assessmentâ€, Fifth Edition, Sounders Elsevier, Philadelphia,2008

Maund E., Craig, D., Suekarran, S., Neilson, A.R., Wright, K., Brealey, S., Dennis, L., Goodchild, L., Hanschood, N., Rangan, G., Richardson, G., Robertson, J., McDaid, C,“Management of frozen shoulder a systematic review and cost effectiveness analysisâ€,Health Technology Assessment, 16(11): 1-264,2012

Neumann, D.A,“Kinesiology of the musculoskletal system, Foundations for Rehabilitationâ€,Second Edition, Missouri 63043, Mosby Elsevier,2010

Pocock,“Clinical Trials A Practical Approachâ€, A Willey Medical Publication, New York,2008

Robinson, C.M., Seah, K.T.M., Chee, Y.H., Hindle, P., Murray, I.R,“Frozen shoulderâ€,The Journal of Bone and Joint surgery, 94-B (1): 1-9,2012

Salim, J.S., Siahaan, T,“Terapi MLDV meningkatkan LGS dan kemampuan fungsional sendi glenohumeralis dengan cepat pada beberapa pasien penderita frozen shoulderâ€, Medan,2011

Stenvers, J.D,“Primary frozen shoulder frequent asked questionsâ€,2009. Available from: URL: http://www.nsastenvers.nl

Vizniak, N.A,“Quick Reference Evidence-Based Physical Assessmentâ€, Third Edition, Profesional Health Systems,Canada, 2010

Wies, J,“Treatment of eight patients with frozen shoulder; a case study seriesâ€, Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, 9: 58-64,2005

Wilk, K.E., Macrina, L.C, Arrigo., C,“Shoulder Rehabilitation in Physical Rehabilition of the Injured Athleteâ€, 4th Edition, Elsevier Sounders,Philadelphia, 2012

Wittlinger, G,“Texbook of Dr. Vodder’s Manual Lymph Drainage Vodderâ€, 7th Edition, Thieme,Stuttgart, 2004

Yang, J.L., Chang, C.W., Chen, S.Y., Wang., S.F., Lin, J.J,“Mobilization techniques in subjects with frozen shoulder syndrome; randomized multiple-treatment trialâ€, Phys Ther, 87: 1307-1315,2007

Zuther, J.E,“Lymphedema Managementâ€, 2nd Edition, Thieme, Stuttgart, New York,2009




DOI: https://doi.org/10.47007/fisio.v14i1.1107

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


 

View My Stats