INTERVENSI MULLIGAN BENT LEG RAISE EXERCISE LEBIH BAIK DARI PADA MC. KENZIE EXTENSION EXERCISEDALAM MENURUNKANNYERI DAN DISABILITAS PADA KASUS NYERI PINGGANG MIOGENIK DI RS.BAYUKARTA

Dwi Lestiana, Sugijanto Sugijanto

Abstract


Abstract

Object : to prove Mulligan bent leg raise is better than  Mc. Kenzie extension exercise  to reduce pain and disability in miogenik low back pain. Methods : experimental. Sampel are 10 employers at Bayukarta hospital. Choosen by purposive sampling.Results : after 12 times exercise. Hypothesis I using  paired sample t-test obtained VAS average before (58.40±3.91) and after (35.00±5.61) then p =0.001 and ODI average  before (38.80±2.28)  and after (21.00±8.94) then p =0.006 which means Mulligan bent leg raise can reduce pain and disability. Hypothesis II using paired sample t-test obtained VAS value before (57.20±7.62) and after (37.60±8.20) then p< 0.001  and ODI using Wilcoxon test, average before (44.80±5.01) and after (30.80±8.43) then  p=0.042 which means Mc. Kenzie extension exercise can reduce pain and disability. On hypothesis III using Mann Whitney u-test  obtained ODI average difference of one (21.00±8.94) and two (30.80±8.43) then  p = 0.249  and VAS using independent t-test obtained after one (58.40±3.91) and two  (57.20 ±7.62)  p=0.575 which meaning  Mulligan bent leg raise is not better than  Mc. Kenzie extension exercise. Conclution: Mulligan bent leg raise is not better than  Mc. Kenzie extension exercise to reduce pain and disability in miogenik low back pain at Rs. Bayukarta. 

               

Keywords : Mulligan bent leg raise exercise, Mc. Kenzie extension exercise, pain, disability.

Abstrak

Tujuan :Untuk membuktikan intervensi Mulligan bent leg raise exercise lebih baik dari pada Mc. Kenzie extension exercisedalam menurunkannyeri dan disabilitaspada nyeri pinggangmiogenik. Metode :eksperimental.10 sampel pegawaidi RS.Bayukarta,tekniknyapurposive sampling.Hasil : setelah 12 kali latihan. Hipotesis I menggunakanpaired sample t-test, VAS rerata sebelum (58.40±3.91) dan sesudah (35.00±5.61)maka p=0.001danODI rerata sebelum (38.80±2.28)dan sesudah (21.00±8.94) maka p=0.006berartiintervensiMulligan bentlegraisedapatmenurunkannyeridandisabilitas. Hipotesis II menggunakanpaired sample t-testdanWilcoxon testdidapatkanVAS rerata sebelum (57.20±7.62) dan sesudah (37.60±8.20)maka p<0.001dan ODI rerata sebelum (44.80±5.01)dan sesudah (30.80±8.43) makap= 0.042 berartiintervensiMc. Kenzie extension exercisedapatmenurunkannyeridandisabilitas. Hipotesis III menggunakanMann Whitneyu-test,ODI rerata selisih 1 (21.00±8.94) dan 2 (30.80±8.43) maka p=0.249dan VAS menggunakanindependen t-test didapat rerata sesudah 1 (58.40±3.91) dan 2 (57.20 ±7.62) maka  p=0.575 yang berartiintervensiMulligan bentlegraisetidak lebihbaikdaripadaMc. Kenzie extension exercisedalammenurunkannyeridandisabilitas. Kesimpulan :IntervensiMulligan bentlegraisesama baiknya denganMc. Kenzie extension exercise dalam menurunkan nyeri dan disabilitas pada kasus nyeri pinggang miogenik di Rs.Bayukarta.

 

Kata Kunci :Mulligan bent leg raise exercise, Mc. Kenzie extension exercise,nyeri, disabilitas.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Daftar Pustaka

Borestein and Wissel. (2004). Low Back Pain Medical Diagnosis and Comprehensive Management. WB sauder company. Philadelpia.

Bull, E. (2007). Nyeri Punggung: Erlangga. Jakarta.

Chou, Roger.(2011). Clinical Evidence Handbook Low Back Pain (Chronic). Amerika. Oregon Health & Science University Portland Oregon.

Fairbank JC, Pynsent PB. (2000). TheOswestry Disability Index. Discussion 52.

Garcia, Alessandra Narciso et.al.(2013). Effectiveness of Back School Versus Mc. Kenzie Exercises in Patient With Chronic Nonspecific Low Back Pain : A Randomized Controlled Trial. Brazil :UniversidadeCidade De Sao Paulo.

Gerwin, RD dan mense. Siiegfried.(2010). Muscle Pain Diagnosis and Treatmen. Springer.

Hall, Toby. (2006). Manual Therapy II School of Physiotherapy, curtin unuversity of technology, Bentley, western.Australia. 130-135.

______ Mulligant Bent., (2005) Leg raise Technique a Preliminary Randomized Trial of Immediate Effects after a Single Intervension. 2005. Australia.

Hills, E.C. (2006). Mechanical Low Back Pain. Retrieved; 15 Agustus 20016. http://www emedicine.com.

Idyan, Zamna. (2007). Hubungan Lama Duduk Saat Perkuliahan Dengan Keluhan Low Back Pain. http//www.innappni.or.id.

Kisner & Colby. (2007). Therapeutic Exercise Foundation and Technique 5th ed. Philadelphia:F.A David Company.

Keating, D.M.(2002). A comparison of Five Low Back Disability Questionnaires: Realibility and Responsiveness. Physical Therapy 2002,82:8-24.

Magee, D.J. (2013). Orthopedic Condition and Treatment. six edition, W.B.Saunder company, Philadelpia.

Marpaung & Sjah, (2006). Penatalaksanaan Nyeri Punggung Kronis. Temu Ilmiah Reumatologi, Jakarta 14-16.

Meliala, L dan Pinzon, R. (2004). Patofisiologi dan Penatalaksanaan Nyeri Pinggang Bawah. Dalam: Meliala, L, Rusdi, gofis, A, editor pada simposium: Towards mechanic based treadment. Jogjakarta.

Mulligan, B, R. (2010). Manual Therapy:â€Nagsâ€,â€Snagsâ€,†Mwmsâ€etc. Sixth edition. New Zealand.

.(2004). Manual Therapy:â€Nagsâ€,â€Snagsâ€,†Mwmsâ€etc. Plane view services.wellington:70-71.

Mc.Kenzie,R. (2000). 7 Step to a Pain Free Life. pingguin putnam Inc. New york.

. (2006). Treat Your Back. New zealand. Spinal publication ltd.

Mc. Kenzie, R, may, S. (2008). The Cervical and Thoracalis Spine Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy. Volume one. Spinal publications. Newzeland.

R, Putzand, R, Pabst. (2007). Atlas Anatomi Manusia. Sobotta anatomi. Edisi 2. Buku kedokteran EGC. Jakarta.

Resdiani. Pemberian Intervensi Mulligan bent leg raise Lebih Baik Dalam Menurunkan Nyeri Fungsional LBP Non Spesifik Daripada Pemberian Intervensi Mc.Kenzie exercise Pada Buruh Angkut Beras di Desa Mengesta, Tabanan. Bagian Farmakologi Fakultas Kedokteran Universitas Udayana. Majalah Ilmiah Fisioterapi Indonesia. Volume 2.

Samara D. (2004). Lama dan Sikap Duduk Sebagai Faktor Resiko Terjadinya Nyeri Pinggang Bawah. Kedokteran Trisakti. 23.

Simon, G, David. (1999) Myofacial Pain and Dysfunction The Triger Poin Manual. Volume I. USA.

Tarwaka, Solichul, dan Lilik, S.(2004). Ergonomi Untuk Keselamatan Kerja dan Produktivitasnya. Unisba Press. Surabaya.

Paatelma, Markku. (2008). Orthopaedic Manual Therapy, Mc. Kenzie Method or Advice Only for Low Back Pain in Working Adults: A Randomized Controlled Trial With One Year Follow-Up. Canada.

Phansopkar, A, Pratik. (2014). Efficacy of Mulligan’s Two Leg Rotation And Bent Leg Raise Techniques In Hamstring Flexibility In Subjects with Acute Low Back Pain: A Randomized Controlled Trial.

Phil, Page. (2010). Asessment and Treadment of Muscle Imbalance (The Janda Approach). Chicago.

Patel, G, (2014). To Compare the Effectiveness of Mulligant Bent Leg Raising and Slump Streching in Patient With Low Back Pain, Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. 8: 24-28.

Pawar, A, H, (2014). “Comparative Effectiveness of Mulligan’s Traction Straight Leg Raise and Bent Leg Raise in Low Back Ache with Radiculopathyâ€. A Randomized Clinical Trial. International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR).6-10.

Pocock, S,J. (2008). Clinical Trials A Practical Approach. John Wile and Sons. England:128.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.47007/fisio.v17i2.2214

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


 

View My Stats